Cognitive Restructuring: Thoughts on Trial Worksheet Free PDF Download example
Page 1 of 2

Download the worksheet (PDF)

What is the Thoughts on Trial worksheet?

The thoughts on trial worksheet runs a courtroom metaphor over three steps. The client names the thought on trial, then fills two facing columns of evidence for and against it. A final verdict states whether the thought is fair and accurate.

How to use the Thoughts on Trial worksheet

Use it in session or as homework. The two evidence columns are the work, and the sheet’s own instruction is worth repeating aloud: focus on the facts and be honest. Clients tend to fill the supporting column quickly and stall on the other, which is itself the finding. Your clients can then write the verdict. Step three asks for an alternative explanation, which stops the exercise ending on a judgement with nothing to replace it.

Thoughts on Trial Worksheet Download – What’s Included

Two printable pages. Page one states the thought and holds the two evidence columns, for and against. Page two asks for the final verdict and whether the thought is the most likely explanation. It then asks for any alternative thought that fits the same evidence.

Why this worksheet helps

Invest in your clients’ success with this essential tool, helping them to challenge negative thought patterns.

As a mental health professional, you know the power of cognitive restructuring in helping clients overcome negative thought patterns. However, finding effective tools to guide this process can be challenging. That’s where Mentalyc’s Cognitive Restructuring: Thoughts on Trial worksheet comes in handy.

Why Mentalyc’s Cognitive Restructuring: Thoughts on Trial is Essential:

  • It is a practical and engaging tool for your clients
  • It eliminates the need to create materials from scratch
  • This worksheet simplifies the complex process of cognitive restructuring, making it easier for your clients to understand

This Worksheet guides clients through the process of :

  • Identifying the thought to be challenged
  • Gathering supporting and contradicting evidence
  • Considering other possible thoughts
  • Assessing the accuracy of their thoughts given the evidence and alternative options
Used this worksheet in a session?
Mentalyc writes the note for you, including the homework you assigned.
Record or upload the session and get a compliant progress note, treatment plan, and client summary in minutes. More time for the clinical work these worksheets support, less time on paperwork after hours.
Watch real stories from Mentalyc users
HIPAA Compliant, PHIPA, SOC 2 Type II
4.8/5 rating, trusted by 30,000+ therapists
Try Mentalyc for Free
Your Author

Tracy Collins is a licensed clinical psychologist with over six years of direct clinical experience in outpatient and telehealth settings. She specializes in cognitive behavioral therapy, structured treatment planning, and measurable therapy outcomes. Tracy has extensive experience writing SOAP and DAP notes, developing insurance-compliant treatment plans, and aligning documentation with ICD-10 and DSM-5-TR diagnostic criteria. Her clinical approach integrates cognitive behavioral therapy techniques, behavioral activation, exposure-based interventions, and mindfulness-based strategies to create structured and outcome-driven therapy plans. At Mentalyc, Tracy supports therapists by creating educational resources that simplify documentation workflows and improve treatment plan defensibility during audits.

Why other mental health professionals love Mentalyc
Stanley LeMelle 
“Do yourself a favor, make your life easier. I found Mentalyc to be one of the best tools that I’ve ever used.
Stanley LeMelle 
Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist
Amber McKinney
“For anyone hesitant: this is a lifesaver. It will change your life, and you have more time to be present with your patients.
Amber McKinney
Licensed Clinical Social Worker
Dominique Walker
“If I were recommending this software to a colleague, I would tell them that it is the best thing that they could do for their practice.
Dominique Walker
Licensed Professional Counselor
Kara-Myung Jin Purves
“It immediately changed my quality of life, personally and professionally.
Kara-Myung Jin Purves
Owner/Independently Licensed Marriage & Family Therapist (LMFT)
Free PDF worksheet · 2 pages
Download
Print
No sign-up. No PHI collected.

4.8 on Capterra · 30k+ clinicians

Love these worksheets?

Mentalyc handles the notes and treatment plans too.

Try Mentalyc free

no card · works with your EHR · HIPAA