Therapeutic Alliance in Psychoanalysis & Psychoanalytic Treatment
Have your progress notes written for you
automatically
In the world of psychoanalysis, the therapeutic alliance is more than just a professional bond—it is the crucible for emotional growth, self-discovery, and psychic integration. Rooted in mutual respect, a shared commitment to the process, and the capacity to withstand emotional turbulence, the alliance in psychoanalytic therapy creates a unique space where the unconscious can be safely explored. Unlike short-term or solution-focused therapies, psychoanalysis requires a sustained and intimate relationship between patient and analyst—one that evolves through phases of attunement, rupture, insight, and repair. This guide delves into the nature, development, and long-term significance of the therapeutic alliance in psychoanalytic work.
What is the Therapeutic Alliance in Psychoanalysis and Psychoanalytic Treatment?
The therapeutic alliance refers to the collaborative and emotional connection between patient and therapist that supports the work of therapy. In psychoanalytic treatment, this alliance is more than a cooperative partnership—it is a vital, emotionally charged relationship that facilitates the regression, transference, and eventual reorganization of the psyche. Freud originally conceptualized this bond as a “positive transference” that enables the patient to stay engaged despite resistance.
It’s important to note that this alliance operates on multiple levels simultaneously: the conscious agreement on therapy goals and tasks, the unconscious emotional currents shaped by the patient’s early attachments, and the here-and-now emotional reality of two people in a room. This multilayered nature makes the psychoanalytic alliance especially complex and powerful.
How the Alliance Develops in Psychoanalytic Therapy
The development of the alliance in psychoanalysis is gradual and recursive. It begins with the analyst’s consistent presence, empathic listening, and emotional availability. Unlike more directive modalities, the analyst offers containment and reflection rather than solutions or advice.
Over time, the alliance deepens as the patient begins to trust the analytic frame—knowing that sessions will occur regularly, that their material will be met without judgment, and that difficult feelings can be tolerated. This reliable structure enables the emergence of the transference, which is not a disruption but a central component of the work. When handled with care, transference experiences enrich the alliance rather than erode it (Barsness, 2021.)
Importance of Therapeutic Alliance in Psychoanalytic Treatment
The alliance provides the emotional scaffolding needed for the analytic process to unfold. It is within this relationship that patients revisit early relational injuries, re-experience core anxieties, and begin to revise long-standing internal narratives.
A strong alliance offers psychological safety, which is essential for engaging with painful and defended parts of the self. It also allows the therapist to offer interpretations that challenge defenses and encourage insight. Without a stable and trusting alliance, such interventions might feel invasive or shaming. Thus, the therapeutic alliance not only supports therapy—it is the medium through which therapy happens.
Measuring Therapeutic Alliance in Psychoanalysis
Though often considered a qualitative experience, the therapeutic alliance in psychoanalysis can be measured with various tools adapted for psychodynamic contexts. Instruments such as the Working Alliance Inventory (WAI), the California Psychotherapy Alliance Scales (CALPAS), and observer-based coding systems like the Psychotherapy Process Q-set (PQS) provide frameworks for assessing the quality and strength of the alliance.
Analysts also use narrative methods—such as process notes, supervision discussions, and case formulations—to track alliance ruptures, transference dynamics, and progress over time. The subjective experience of both patient and therapist remains a critical diagnostic tool in assessing the alliance (Núñez et al., 2021.)
Long-Term Alliance Building in Psychoanalytic Work
Psychoanalysis often spans years, and the alliance must be strong enough to weather the inevitable storms of emotional regression, therapeutic misattunement, and resistance. Early in treatment, the focus may be on establishing safety and predictability. As therapy progresses, deeper conflicts and unconscious defenses emerge, often testing the bond between therapist and patient.
Over the long arc of analysis, ruptures and repairs within the alliance become vehicles for healing. Repeated experiences of being understood, held, and responded to with thoughtfulness begin to reshape the patient’s internal world. These new relational templates can replace maladaptive ones developed in early life, creating lasting internal change.
Take your time back! Get your progress notes done automatically
Therapist Neutrality and Its Impact on the Alliance
In classical psychoanalysis, therapist neutrality was considered essential for allowing the transference to emerge. The analyst, by refraining from self-disclosure and avoiding overt emotional reactions, served as a “blank screen” onto which the patient could project unconscious material (Tschuschke et al., 2022.)
However, modern analysts recognize that pure neutrality can be alienating, especially for patients with histories of relational trauma. Today, neutrality is reframed as attuned abstinence—a stance that preserves analytic integrity while remaining emotionally responsive. The therapist avoids colluding with defenses but remains empathically engaged, striking a careful balance between emotional availability and technical restraint.
Case Examples of Therapeutic Alliance in Psychoanalysis
Case Example 1: Reconstructing Trust Through Alliance
A patient with complex trauma repeatedly tests the therapist’s reliability by arriving late, canceling appointments, and accusing the therapist of not caring. Rather than react defensively, the therapist explores the meaning behind these actions, linking them to earlier abandonment. Through repeated empathic engagement and firm boundaries, the alliance becomes a reparative experience of reliability.
Case Example 2: Transference as a Window into the Alliance
A client begins idealizing the analyst as a perfect parent figure. The therapist recognizes the positive transference and uses it to explore the patient’s unmet childhood needs. As the therapy deepens, this idealization gives way to anger and disappointment. The therapist helps the patient explore these feelings, strengthening the alliance by demonstrating that the relationship can withstand difficult emotions.
Alliance in Modern Psychoanalytic Approaches
Contemporary psychoanalytic theories have evolved to place the therapeutic relationship at the center of the work. In relational psychoanalysis, for instance, the alliance is viewed as co-constructed and mutually influencing. The analyst is not merely an observer of the patient’s mind but a participant in a shared intersubjective field.
Attachment-based and intersubjective psychoanalysis further emphasize the therapeutic alliance as a corrective emotional experience. These models invite a more flexible, transparent therapist stance—one that honors the patient’s vulnerabilities while offering authentic connection. The alliance is not just a means to an end—it becomes a living experience of growth, attunement, and repair (Brambilla, Bressi and Biagianti, 2022.)
Transference and Countertransference as Components of the Alliance
In psychoanalysis, the alliance cannot be separated from the transference and countertransference. The patient brings unconscious relational templates to the therapeutic relationship—projecting past experiences, unmet needs, and unresolved conflicts onto the therapist. Meanwhile, the therapist’s own emotional responses (countertransference) become valuable data about the patient’s internal world.
Increase your practice's revenue and reduce therapist burnout
Understanding and interpreting these dynamics in the context of the alliance can lead to profound insights. Rather than pathologizing transference reactions, the analyst works within them—allowing the alliance to serve as a space where distorted relational patterns are brought into awareness and transformed.
Repairing Ruptures in the Psychoanalytic Alliance
Alliance ruptures are inevitable in any long-term psychoanalytic treatment. What distinguishes effective therapy is not the absence of rupture, but the capacity to recognize and repair it. Ruptures may manifest as withdrawal, passive aggression, missed appointments, or overt conflict.
The analyst’s task is to explore these disruptions openly and non-defensively. By making space for the patient’s grievances and exploring their meaning, the therapist models healthy relational repair. Successful resolution of these moments often leads to a deepening of trust and a greater sense of emotional safety (Mylona, Avdi and Paraskevopoulos, 2023.)
The Therapeutic Frame and Its Role in Alliance
The psychoanalytic frame—the consistent structure of time, setting, boundaries, and rules—is essential to the development of a strong alliance. It provides containment and predictability, allowing the patient to relax into the process. When the frame is broken (e.g., through missed sessions, boundary violations, or schedule changes), the alliance may be strained.
A well-maintained frame communicates respect for the work and for the patient. It also becomes a symbol of the therapist’s reliability, helping the patient internalize a stable and trustworthy relational model (Glass and Bickler, 2021.) The frame supports the alliance by creating a secure foundation for the exploration of difficult psychic material.
Alliance Challenges in Remote Psychoanalysis
In the age of teletherapy, psychoanalytic work increasingly occurs over video or phone. While this medium poses unique challenges—such as screen fatigue, disembodiment, and reduced nonverbal cues—many therapists and patients report that the alliance can remain strong, and in some cases even deepen due to increased accessibility and intimacy.
However, the analyst must pay closer attention to subtle shifts in tone, gaze, and timing. Technical issues or environmental distractions can disrupt the rhythm of the session and strain the alliance. Clear communication, attention to the virtual frame, and regular check-ins about the medium are essential to preserving the therapeutic relationship (Glass and Bickler, 2021.)
Takeaway
The therapeutic alliance in psychoanalysis is not a passive backdrop to the work—it is the very substance through which healing, insight, and psychic transformation unfold. Rooted in mutual engagement, shaped by transference and countertransference, and sustained through empathy and containment, the alliance becomes a powerful force for change.
In a world where superficial solutions are often prioritized, psychoanalytic therapy invites us to slow down, to feel, and to relate deeply. The alliance offers a new experience of being known, accepted, and emotionally held. And in that space—over weeks, months, and years—the patient not only heals from the past but begins to reimagine their future.
Reference
Barsness, R. E. (2021). Therapeutic practices in relational psychoanalysis: A qualitative study. Psychoanalytic Psychology, 38(1), 22.
Núñez, L., Midgley, N., Capella, C., Alamo, N., Mortimer, R., & Krause, M. (2021). The therapeutic relationship in child psychotherapy: integrating the perspectives of children, parents and therapists. Psychotherapy Research, 31(8), 988-1000.
Tschuschke, V., Koemeda-Lutz, M., von Wyl, A., Crameri, A., & Schulthess, P. (2022). The impact of clients’ and therapists’ characteristics on therapeutic alliance and outcome. Journal of Contemporary Psychotherapy, 52(2), 145-154.
Brambilla, P., Bressi, C., & Biagianti, B. (2022). An attachment-based framework for disordered personality development: Implications for intersubjective psychodynamic psychotherapy. Frontiers in Psychiatry, 13, 970116.
Mylona, A., Avdi, E., & Paraskevopoulos, E. (2023). Alliance rupture and repair processes in psychoanalytic psychotherapy: Multimodal in-session shifts from momentary failure to repair. In Therapeutic Failures in Psychotherapy (pp. 98-125). Routledge.
Glass, V. Q., & Bickler, A. (2021). Cultivating the therapeutic alliance in a telemental health setting. Contemporary Family Therapy, 43(2), 189-198.
